Interdisciplinarity and funding within Nordic energy research

The Finnish journal Tieteessä Tapahtuu [Science Now] has just published the article Monitieteisyyden ja tutkimusrahoituksen näkökulma pohjoismaiseen energiatutkimukseen [An interdisciplinary and research funding perspective on Nordic energy research] written by…

The Finnish journal Tieteessä Tapahtuu [Science Now] has just published the article Monitieteisyyden ja tutkimusrahoituksen näkökulma pohjoismaiseen energiatutkimukseen [An interdisciplinary and research funding perspective on Nordic energy research] written by Antti Silvast, Senior Adviser at Nordic Energy Research.

The article focuses on interdisciplinarity and funding within Nordic energy research and draws on some of the experiences that Nordic Energy Research has gained in connection with the call management of the Era-NET Smart Energy Systems (SES) since 2015.

Research funding and interdisciplinarity
In the article, Antti Silvast provides an overview of interdisciplinary energy research and presents an evaluation model that Nordic Energy Research has used to evaluate the interdisciplinarity of a research project. In addition, Antti Silvast presents his experiences with interdisciplinary evaluation and its need for development.

The main message of the article is about how research funders should become better at appreciating interdisciplinary topics and supporting such topics in the evaluation process. It is well-known that interdisciplinary research projects may have more difficult access to funding compared to conventional projects from a single academic discipline. Interdisciplinarity is a popular topic in university strategies and research policies but has yet not become an integral part of research funding practice.

As an example of an exception Antti Silvast highlights the 3-layer model of the ERA-Net SES as a model for interdisciplinary evaluation that involves different experts (e.g. electrical engineers, economists, social scientists) in the evaluation of specific proposals. Antti Silvast explains the principles of the 3-layer evaluation model to the Finnish world of research and funding in an attempt to increase awareness of the evaluation model and receive feedback from Finnish experts.

The 3-layer model of the ERA-Net SES
Like all evaluation models, the 3-layer model of the ERA-Net SES requires continuous maintenance and is constantly evolving. The experience from ERA-Net emphasizes interdisciplinarity and disagreements.

Firstly, it is important to maintain the interdisciplinary evaluation developed in ERA-Net SES. Not least, because energy research increasingly recognizes the value of interdisciplinary research that crosses conventional academic disciplines. Secondly, evaluation methods which recognize disagreements between evaluators have potential and should be further used in the future.

Interdisciplinarity must never replace research-based content
Even though Antti Silvast is a proponent of interdisciplinarity he concludes the article by emphasizing the importance of research-based content. In the future all evaluators within research funding should continue to focus on research-related content and not just the amount of interdisciplinarity.

Antti Silvast

Position:
Senior Adviser
Email:
antti.silvast@nordicenergy.org
Phone:
+47 458 40 078

Sign up for our newsletter

Nordic Energy Research (NER) collects and processes personal information via its web page nordicenergy.org and other domains that Nordic Energy Research has registered for its various programs and activities.  Personal information is provided on a voluntary basis when visiting these web pages. The processing of personal information in connection with the services we offer, such as subscribing to newsletters and events, is done with the consent of the user.  We do no share user information with any third parties without the express permission of the user. Lundgren + Lindqvist AB provides operational and maintenance services to nordicenergy.org.   Lundgren + Lindqvist acts as a data processor for the NER, and it is only NER and Lundgren + Lindqvist who have access to the information. The company MailChimp delivers the solution for these newsletters and acts as a data processor for Nordic Energy Research in accordance with the agreement we have made with them. In order to send e-mail to the right recipient we must save your name and e-mail address. We may also save other information you choose to provide, such as organisation and work title. This information is stored in the MailChimp database. We will not share your information with third parties without your express permission, and we delete your information when you end your subscription. We will use the information only to manage the sending of newsletters or event invitations. You must unsubscribe, via the link in the newsletter or on the mailchimp website, if you no longer want to receive newsletters.